Why True Stories Beat Traditional Ads

People have gotten very good at ignoring ads. They skip them, scroll past them, and tune out anything that feels like a pitch. What they don't skip is a good story about real people. That's why most of the film work we do is built around true stories, and why we think more brands should do the same.

People can tell when something is real

Viewers have seen every trick. Polished actors, staged smiles, a voiceover telling them how to feel. It reads as an ad within a second or two, and they're gone. A real person talking about their real work holds attention in a way scripted content rarely does, because there's something to actually watch.

Our work with Fire Salt is the clearest proof we have. Over two years we produced more than 25 shoots with wildland crews and firefighters, including FDNY and multiple hotshot crews. We didn't hire talent. The people on screen were the people who use the product on the job. That work reached more than 140 million organic views, and it held up because it was honest about the work those crews do.

Stories last longer than campaigns

A traditional ad is built for a moment: a launch, a sale, a season. A good story keeps working. Brand films get watched again, shared, and pulled into sales decks, websites, and social for years after they're made.

YETI Presents is a great example. Instead of telling you how tough the coolers are, YETI makes short documentaries about people who live the life the product is built for. You can watch those films without caring about coolers at all, and you walk away thinking more of the brand anyway.

The product doesn't have to be the hero

This is the hardest part for a lot of brands to accept. In a true story, the product is often in the background. It's on the truck, in the pack, on the shelf of the store. The story is about the people. That's what earns the attention, and the brand gets credit for telling it.

When we worked on After the Uniform, a film series about veterans commissioned by Adobe, there was no product to sell at all. Just stories. The series went on to screen at three film festivals and pick up awards at each. It's a good reminder that what people respond to is the story, not the pitch.

What a true story needs

  • Real people. Customers, employees, founders, the community a brand serves.

  • A reason to watch. Something at stake, a question, a turn. Not just a list of good things about the brand.

  • Restraint. Let moments breathe. Don't explain everything with voiceover.

  • A small crew. We keep our crews lean, usually three to five people. People are more themselves when there isn't a film set's worth of gear in their face.

  • Honesty about the brand. The story has to match what the brand actually is, or it falls apart.

When a traditional ad still makes sense

We're not against ads. A product launch, a sale, or a direct response campaign often needs something short and to the point. The best approach is usually both: a true story that builds the brand over time, and shorter cuts and ads that come from the same shoot and put it to work.

That's how we plan most productions. One shoot, a brand film at the center, and a set of shorter edits and stills around it. You can see some of that work on our film page, or get in touch if you have a story worth telling.

Benjamin Steele

Through my determination and entrepreneurial attitude, I plan to make a difference in the world.

http://www.bensteele.com
Previous
Previous

How to Plan a Brand Film People Actually Watch

Next
Next

How to Build a Meaningful Brand That Connects